Earlier this month APANSO was launched – a non-profit association representing private air navigation services mainly within the European Union. Raquel Martínez Arnáiz is the APANSO Chairwoman spoke with Philip Butterworth-Hayes on the aims of the organisation and what it wants to change.
Why have you launched this association?
About a year ago Skyway and ACR got together and found out that even though we were in different countries with different environments we had the same barriers and problems. This is not related to the local provision of air traffic control in competitive environments but is wider than that: we are operating in the same areas as public organisations but with our own very particular conditions.
So we decided that it was a good time bring a new voice to the ATM policy debate in Europe. Of course CANSO represents the interest of ANSPs from different perspectives and interests but we think our view has been missing in the European debate. The challenges we have are often institutional and political but companies like ours do not, as individual entities, get an opportunity to be heard. So to combine the common interests of these private companies fighting for survival in this heavily monopolistic dominated system it only makes sense to join together.
What kind of “conditions” do privately owned ANSPs uniquely face?
All of them have to do with the fact that we need to prove our value to the customer, which is not always the case with state-owned ANSPs. For example, we have a contract with the airport operator so the terms and conditions are clear for both sides if there’s a situation in which we are not able to meet agreed levels of service. For example, if we cannot open the airport at the right time because we have staffing problems or we are not able to meet the demand agreed in the contract then we face a penalty. We have to show continuous improvement. These contracts need to be reviewed so there will be another tender at the end of the contract and then we need to prove again that our proposal is the best from different options. So that’s very different from normal airport ATM arrangements.
And of course we are constantly focused on safety. For APANSO members safety is literally existential in a way that frankly and with all due respect, it is not for others who are in a sovereign monopoly position.
What do you want to change?
We want to improve the performance of the aviation system in Europe through the introduction of more competition. That’s the main mission. We have a white paper now focused on terminal services and our vision is that current regulation, from 2024, should be changed from Member States “may” tender these services to “must”, so they can choose the best option, whether that’s a state-owned ANSP or a private one. We also have proposals for RP5 to change behaviour and results. We want to make it mandatory for each airport to have a service level agreement with their ANSP – something that is quite basic but not in place in most cases. This is to make sure that ANSP performance is measured not just through the performance scheme but are forced to comply with other indicators, so that they are they are accountable to the airport through a service level agreement (SLA). We think that there should be a single indicator included in the SLA that measures both the cost of the services itself and the cost of the delays so you can measure quality and not just cost.
We are proposing that the system should be able to apply consequences if there’s a persistent under performance.
Which areas does APANSO seek to operate – airports, en-route, UTM? Within Europe or beyond?
Our initial white paper is based on air traffic management and terminal services but we want to represent ANS widely, so we are talking about training, met services and CNS. You mentioned UTM which is a new thing, quite interesting and maybe there’s a change there to what is being done in ATM currently. ANS is the focus of our two founding members, that’s our natural habitat, but we want to be wider than that. We are focusing on Europe right now, there’s a lot of policy debate, changes in regulation going on so that’s our immediate focus.
When private companies enter the ANS value chain the primary first effect is that you get lower costs and Europe in particular is burdened by very high costs. The seven regional airports in Switzerland cost the taxpayer annually a recurring cost of 35 million Swiss francs which is way beyond any kind of benchmark. We don’t see ANS as a natural monopoly. You can argue that the en-route segment might be a natural monopoly because it doesn’t make sense to duplicate infrastructure, but training, CNS, terminal ANS, UTM all have nothing to do with being an actual monopoly.
The ATM master plan which sets out the digital future of Europe’s airspace infrastructure, is focused on new service areas such as surveillance-as-a-service, for example. Is that the sort of market you’re looking at or are you more focused on ANS service provision?
The members right now have a knowledge and expertise and practical data in ATM but we want to have new members that can represent other areas of air navigation services in the widest sense. We want to make sure that we have sufficient practical data and evidence so that we can influence the political debate in the right way. We are talking to companies in the met and training sectors that tell us they are experiencing the same problems as us. The area you mention is extremely relevant to us because we believe private data management companies in future will be an important part of the ATM universe. If they are private, they are most welcome. We have an interest from a digital AIM company that wants to join us; as long as they are not state owned they will be welcome.
In terms of the drone sector in principle, they’re welcome too. We have been worried because there are so many of these companies out there, now that they would turn the organisation into a drone industry group. But we’re still in the launch phase so we can go in any direction.
You’re talking about a formal industry launch in 2027 – what’s that going to look like and how many members will you have?
We’ve had a lot of interest from the publications we developed for our initial launch last week. We are now analysing this and seeing how we want to work with these potential members.
How do you define a private ANS company?
It needs to have separate accounting from any regulated state aid. That’s what makes us different from other associations. For example, Air Navigation Solutions in the UK used to operate Gatwick and now operates Edinburgh. There were very interested, but DFS is a shareholder so they do not qualify.
Do you think in Europe there is a growing political appetite for private ATM service provision and competition will be welcomed?
There’s been a change in the framework regulation for the Single European Sky so for the first time the European Commission has introduced the concept of provision of ANS services in the terminal area under micro market conditions. It was not forbidden before but it was not in the regulation. Now it’s a tool that member states can use to achieve the aims of the Single European Sky. We have had conversations with the European Commission before we launched this project and we believe the Commission is convinced that this is the way forward.
As it is, there are barriers in that some Member States not willing to take this step, but there are also some exceptions. I think those opposed are really the exceptions, now. In Spain, the ministry supports a competitive environment for ANS services in airports, so it works, also in Sweden and Switzerland. You can see the benefits that competition has brought to states have decided to go forward it and from these there’s no opposition.
We think this is something the European Commission will continue to push forward and we are here to make sure that we provide the data and examples of the benefits. We want to help other member states take this step but are unsure on how to do it.
And has there been any contact with any airlines about the work of your association?
Not yet. But we have met with representative associations and they are interested in what we are saying and our proposals to improve the system. But we are not trying to impose anything; we are trying to give Member States a choice and decide what model they want to have in each airport so they have better performance through transparency and choice.
Have you spoken to any controllers about this yet?
Not yet. But we are planning to do this.
Within the ATM Masterplan there is the mission of moving towards a single, digital European sky, where the roles of controllers will change as automation and AI take over many of the controller’s mundane tasks. How do you, as an association, feel removing the humans from many decision-making processes?
That’s a question not for the association but for the individual providers. I don’t see a fully digital autonomous system controlling the skies above Europe in the near or even the mid term future.
This interview first appeared in our sister publication Global Airspace Radar



